WYSWIG not adding tags

I cannot seem to get <p> tags to insert themselves on my pages or blog posts. I’ve found several posts online on folks who DON’T want <p> tags automatically inserted, but my client will need this functionality, and I’ve never run into an issue like this before as WP usually has them render by default.

I searched around in the functions.php file and found that wpautop is on.

Here’s a sample page: https://shauners.com/breakroom/about/history/

As you can see, <p> tags are not inserted in the markup, resulting in one single paragraph in the content.