I found the issue, and it was not with the plugin. The issue was with the following code from the Roots (https://roots.io/) framework I had running.
lib/scripts.php
file:
if (!is_admin() && current_theme_supports('jquery-cdn')) {
wp_deregister_script('jquery');
wp_register_script('jquery', $assets['jquery'], array(), null, true);
add_filter('script_loader_src', 'roots_jquery_local_fallback', 10, 2);
}
Removing this bit of code clears up the issue. If others are having this issue scan your code for scripts that potentially remove/add jquery scripts.