Thank-you! You were right, I’m using “Types” plugin to create the custom fields and the slug name it shows is different than what shows up in Dashboard->Content.
Also I had the values at first,second,third and when I switched them back to 1,2,3 it started working!
so a combination of using number values(which I wouldn’t think would matter) and most importantly using the right slug name.
Thank you so much for helping me!
Blake