@lucianwpwhite ,
Thanks for getting back to me.
The site was cloned back in August last year. The 2FA was only installed on the clone in April. The clone is our dev for the site, try to break things there before we do in prod.
I set the deletion flag and removed the plugin from both the prod site and the clone site. Re-installed it and set it back on the prod site – does not set up 2FA and retuns the user to the top of their profile page.