Hey @k2eric !
First off, thank you so much for replying. I just tried that out and found some interesting stuff out. If I use version 2.2.5 (all they had on the site) when coupled with the old database backup, logged out members are able to see members profiles. It’s not so with the later (newer) database. The same problem persists, though, when the plugin is deactivated as stated above. The URL changes when trying to view profiles, white screen of death and all that. My inexperience here is kind of kickin my butt as I cant even imagine how this is happening. I would love to just get rid of the plugin and call it a day, but that only breaks my site. Can you think of any reason a plugin would be able to cause such mayhem upon being deactivated?
Thanks again!