Haha the guys here are giving me so much shit. That worked. Just FYI, I didn’t see any real instructions anywhere that differentiated how setup would be different for existing galleries/images over new ones. I should’ve thought of that, but it might be worth it to put that prominently for other users – that existing images need to be set at individual image level. It may be there and I just missed it.
Is there a way in either version (free or paid) to randomize images so they come up in a different order every time? We’re trying to prevent the first few images from getting all the votes.