DestinyFacts

I think the problem was that my MX record has both my godaddy local c panel email and another record for my office 365 remote email.

I am removing my local one, and changing that setting again to remote mail exchanger.

Will update late tomorrow with progress, thanks.

My donations plugin is not sending emails either. I used Seamless-donations. Do you know what MX record I need to have to make that work?

I tried enabling remote mail exchanger, did not work.

I found this in the cpanel:
Manual Settings
If you do not see an auto-configuration script for your client in the list above, you can manually configure your mail client using the settings below:

Secure SSL/TLS Settings
(Recommended)
Username: [email protected]
Password: Use the email account’s password.
Incoming Server: a2plcpnl0124.prod.iad2.secureserver.net
IMAP Port: 993
POP3 Port: 995
Outgoing Server: a2plcpnl0124.prod.iad2.secureserver.net
SMTP Port: 465

I tried putting in the outgoing server info (above) into the Setup Wizard for step 3. Outgoing Mail server hostname but it still gave me Incorrect authentication data.

Is there anything I can do with this information?
I feel like I am putting in something wrong for the wizard, or I am missing/accidently deleted the MX record the plugin needed.

I dont understand what you mean by using a different service. Does that mean canceling my 365 office account and installing another plugin? Geez ive been trouble shooting this contact form for days now.. is there a faster way to msg someone who can help me?

On the Postman SMTP Setup Wizard Setup

How will the connection to the mail server be established?
Your connection settings depend on what your email service provider offers, and what your WordPress host allows.

Postman recommends ??SMTP-STARTTLS with Password (Plain) authentication to host smtp.office365.com on port 587.

Socket:

?? SMTP – office365.com:587
?? SMTP – office365.com:465
?? SMTP – office365.com:25
?? Mandrill API
?? SendGrid API
Authentication:

Password (requires username and password)
Warning: connected to secureserver.net instead of office365.com.

I enter in smtp.office365.com but it gives me this warning. What do I need to do?