Since I posted this, I completely removed super cache. I still got the same error with Total Cache.
Interestingly, even though it threw a fatal error, it seemed to activate anyway. But, several files and directories were not properly created even tho I had 777’d the wp-content directory. I was battling permissions issues badly.
Ended up removing it and going back to Super Cache. But, I’d like to get this worked out. So far, nothing but problems with Total Cache.