@davidtleblanc
I’m having a similar problem.I switched my homepage for one I’d been working on with noindex, nofollow etc in place. I switched pages about 2 days ago and just noticed the nofollow while checking a different problem.
Have Cloudflare in developement mode and still stays @ nofollow?? All other setting changed – noindex to index etc…
This must be a bug somewhere, either in WordPress SEO or the current version of WordPress (3.8)
It just seems insane that if you toggle any setting on/off you can’t reverse your decision..
Maybe somewhere in the database it can be deleted.