ineptian

I guess it could be the way the buttons are pulling the OG info. But when I look at manually entered OG info, and the OG info entered by yoast, they look the same in the inspector to me. So I am a bit lost on where to turn here, and cant really find anything about this online, so it doesnt seem to be a common issue.

Correct, your plugin does not “control” the share buttons that is correct, but it does “control” the information (opengraph) that those buttons pull, and that information is wrong, or getting messed up somewhere. It is for surely a problem with yoast, because deactivating yoast fixes the issue.

I added a group and it worked for me.

It’s the free version I’m fairly sure. Would the pro version have an option for this?