Thanks to you both. I edited the query as Big Bagel suggested (no luck – still same five posts on every page), and finally ended up removing the query_posts()
block altogether (also no luck).
I decided to go through and clean up what I had just to see if it made a difference. I didn’t catch any other obvious flaws, but I’m sure I missed something. No matter what I do it seems to show the last five posts on the front page, then when I click “Previous Posts”, the URL changes to ../page/2 but shows the exact same five posts.
Here is the cleaned-up code.
Any advice or direction is greatly, greatly appreciated.
–
Jack