GOOD LORD I FIGURED IT OUT!
So WP Super Cache is REALLY REALLY REALLY good at caching. So good that you need another plugin to delete the entire cache that WP Super Cache (and any other caching plugin for that matter) has created. Heres the like to said plugin: https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/wp-super-cache-clear-cache-menu/. This plugin creates Delete All Cache button if you are an admin. The WP Super Cache Delete Cache button that super cache provides only deletes the cache of the current page. I guess the other option is to just do it manually by going into your wp-content folder and deleting everything in your cache folder, but I wouldn’t know since thats not what I did.
I hope this is helpful to someone else.
Thanks me