I’m actually searching for the same advice and came here to the forums for some help. The commercial themes index really doesn’t offer any advice beyond a list of vendors to dig through.
I’m curious if anyone has experience with themes, plugins and the folks at wpmudev.org? While it seems like a no brainer, I’m thinking there is more than one catch. I’ve seen some folks unhappy with their billing procedures, but beyond that – how’s their stuff? Are they respectable?
Sorting through themes at www.ads-software.com is like finding a book at the library without a catalog or call number. There’s no sorting by anything – it sort of dumbfounds me unless I’m missing some secret search and sort portal.
Moving on – are there any drawbacks in going with a themeforest theme from an author who appears to be active in providing updates and support?