This was resolved, I changed my theme and it works as it is supposed to. The theme that I was using before somehow was changing the output of the paypal button code. The s2member support staff is awesome. I highly recommend this plug in. So if you run into this problem just change your theme, or as I am doing creating a subdomain to house all of the features of s2member without changing my site. (Created a new instance of wordpress with a new theme all for s2member.)