Thanks for getting back at me jkhongusc!
I thought the DNS subdomains were setup correctly:
digibastards.nl A - 109.72.85.122 3600
*.digibastards.nl A - 109.72.85.122 3600
digibastards.nl AAAA - 2a00:f10:10a:5:3:b43:80:2 3600
*.digibastards.nl AAAA - 2a00:f10:10a:5:3:b43:80:2 3600
Anything wrong in these settings?