Thank you James!
I have been having problems with plugins blowing up this theme (Amazing Grace, very pretty theme and I’ve been happy with it otherwise) ever since I installed it, so I think I will be looking for a new one after today unless I’m able to get #2 or #3 to work. Usually it’s when I install a new plugin, but I haven’t installed one in a while now; this just happened out of the blue.
Thanks so much again!