Thanks Alan –
They’re not being sent at all. I have 60 members with logins and not one of them (of the 3 I’ve tested) are getting reset links. I don’t even get “new user registration” emails like I used to (I created a new account to verify this).
I’ve checked with HostGator first and they seem to believe it’s a WP error?
Some more info:
I upgraded from shared server to VPS about 2-3 weeks ago. I just now noticed the error of not receiving these specific emails when someone brought it up to me yesterday. I’m not sure how this could have anything to do with it, but I have no other ideas.