mikeyjamjams

Thanks, Mike. I played around with all the Image Size settings, but unfortunately my images were still zooming in just a tad bit too slightly.

It looks like this line of CSS was causing the issue
.wp-tiles-tile-bg{background-size: cover;}

I modified this to:
.wp-tiles-tile-bg{background-size: 100% 100%;}

And, that seems to have done the trick so that my tile images are appearing at their original size.

Marking as resolved

Thanks, Agrumepod. That was it! I was on PHP 5.3 instead of 5.4

Thanks! Second question; how can I upgrade to PHP 5.3+ whenever Version 1.0 is out. Is that dependent on my wordpress theme?