Thanks. Part of our problem is that “preferences” are no longer visible on our sidebar menu for admins. So I can’t say what the PF settings are now, but when we first noticed an issue with subscribers all of the PF user control settings were set to Administrator. We tried changing whatever seemed relevant to Subscriber and that’s when everything broke for admins.
In User Role Editor, Subscribers have access to edit_pf_feed_items and read_private_pf_feed_items.
I’ll email screenshots, in case that helps.