It’s because it’s calling the qtip in a way that is conflicting.
You can fix this until the plugin author makes a fix by going to
buddypress-verified/includes/js/verified.js
and change the jquery at the very bottom from
jQuery(‘[data-tooltip!=””]’).each(function() {
to
jQuery(‘span#bp-verified img,span#bp-verified-header img’).each(function() {
This fixed it for me completely.